We have a winner!
After tasting all of the bread and butter pickles, testers were then tasked with choosing their overall favorite.
The Contenders
How Each Brand Ranked
Mt.
Nine brands of bread and butter pickles.Credit:Robbie Caponetto / Stylist: Mary Beth Wetzel
One tester picked this brand as their favorite bread and butter pickle for topping sandwiches specifically.
Others were off-put by the texture, noting they were missing a good crunch.
A couple who didn’t find them to be too sweet found the flavor to be nice and bold.
Credit:Robbie Caponetto; Stylist: Mary Beth Wetzel
This is another pickle that was not chosen by any testers as their top choice.
One tester did note that because of its tanginess and acidity, that it would be good with charcuterie.
Their unmatched crunchiness, flavor, and freshness won over the editors who participated in our taste test.
