The store-bought pie crust of choice is available at most conventional grocery stores.

And if theres any time to dial in your prepared pie crust game, its the holiday season.

We asked them to dig deep and answer once-and-for all: Which prepared crust is best?

Southern Living Jean Hope’s Chocolate Brownie Pie whole ready to serve

Credit:Greg DuPree, Food Stylist: Ruth Blackburn, Prop Stylist: Christine Keely

They all said the same thing.

Getty/Larry Herfindal

What Is The Best Store-Bought Pie Crust?

We asked multiple recipe tester/developers their go-to prepared pie crust, and their answer was unanimous: Pillsbury.

box of pillsbury pie crusts

Credit:Getty/Larry Herfindal

Because it’s consistent.

you could find it everywhere, and it always tastes the same," said recipe developerNicole Hopper.

“Its not got a very distinct flavor to it.

Ill go [Pillsbury] versus store brand any day.

“Theyre crisp [when baked] and cook up nicely.

Hopper concurred, sharing that she also reaches for the frozen prepared crusts for certain occasions.

“You dont have to worry about crimping those,” she said.

“It looks neat.

Yeah, thats my kind of pie crust,” Mervosh replied with a chuckle.

We couldn’t agree more.