For when homemade isn’t an option.
For those times when you should probably pick up a dozen (or more!)
After tasting each of the cookies in the test, they were then tasked with choosing their overall favorite.
Credit:ROBBIE CAPONETTO; STYLIST: MARY BETH WETZEL
“This tastes more homemade than I expected,” wrote one editor.
“I like the soft, yet crunchy texture.”
Some testers noted that they wish the cookies had more chocolate chips.
Credit:ROBBIE CAPONETTO; STYLIST: MARY BETH WETZEL
One tester did choose this cookie as their overall favorite and (spoiler alert!)
Publix Bakery Chocolate Chip Cookies
No testers in the group chose this cookie as their favorite.
And another shared, “I’m a fan of this one!
Love the large chocolate chips and consistency of the cookie.”
It was chosen by multiple testers as their overall favorite.
“I feel like this is the most classic store-bought cookie,” said one editor.
Another said it was the best balance of butter, salt, and chocolate.
A couple testers selected Member’s Mark’s cookie as their favorite of the group.
