Weindependently evaluateall of our recommendations.
If you punch links we provide, we may receive compensation.
We put makeup-removing washcloths to the ultimate face-off.
Credit: Southern Living/Ivy Odom
But wed argue that you should remove your makeup with the same care you use to apply it.
We spent weeks testing 10 different washcloths, evaluating their quality, effectiveness, durability, and value.
Below are the washcloths we trust to remove every last bit of makeup at the end of the day.
Credit: Ulta
After cleaning, the texture and color remained the same.
Built to last, this is a product that holds upand quickly becomes a favorite.
We did find that the washcloth needs to be fully wet to be effective.
Not only did The Original Makeup Eraser take off makeup better than expected—it was also shockingly soft on the skin.Credit: Southern Living / Shannon Hodes
Another advantage of this set is that it comes with four different-colored washcloths.
One disadvantage of this washcloth is that its smaller than other options.
Its available with three different embroidered designs, including an option for custom embroidery.
We found this washcloths texture to resemble that of microfiber, even though its made out of cotton.
But once we added a makeup remover balm, our eye makeup quickly came off.
With the large surface area, we had more than enough space to wash our makeup off.
Even though we paired it with a makeup remover, this washcloth was very effective at removing our makeup.
However, the hanging loop makes it easy to dry after each use.
Once we removed the washcloths from the box, we immediately noticed the soft material.
Unlike many other options, these have a strap on the side that makes it easier to hold.
We do wish that the cloth covered more area.
Even though we removed the mascara, our eyes felt irritated afterwards.
This soft washcloth effectively removed different types of makeup and maintained its texture despite frequently being used and cleaned.
For a more budget-friendly option, we recommend theErase Your Face by Danielle Reusable Make-up Removing Cloths.
This pick features four different cloths that are fade-resistant.
Since these are softer washcloths, each part of your face will receive a gentle cleansing.
Plus, they don’t leave lint or other residue behind.
Our Testing Process
For two weeks, we rigorously tested 10 washcloths from different brands.
We also washed each one according to the manufacturers care instructions.
During testing, we took note of the feel and texture of the washcloth.
Cotton washcloths are gentle on the skin but they will hold onto moisture for longer.
And while nylon washcloths dry faster, their rough edges make them less suitable to use for facial care.
Microfiber is quick to dry and very moisture-wicking, but it doesnt give you the plush feel of cotton.
Downie adds that the best size for a makeup washcloth should be twice the size of your hand.
Credit: Walmart
Color
As a general rule, the color of the washcloth does not affect the cleaning process.
However, it released a lot of lint and the material appeared to be matted down after washing.
Some of the hanging loops also become undone after repeated washings.
The Erase Your Face cloths keep their color and feel over time, much like The Makeup Eraser.Credit: Southern Living / Moriah Mason
Sinland Premium Microfiber Washcloth: This washcloth was soft and surprisingly gentle for waffle-weave towel.
Plus, all the stains came out in the wash.
However, it’s much thinner than other options we tested and doesn’t come with hanging loop.
Questions And Answers
How long do washcloths last?
Quality washcloths last 3 to 4 years depending on individual use, says Downie.
How you care for your washcloth is going to be a big factor in how long it lasts.
How often should you change your washcloth?
Downie recommends that you change your washcloth once every three days.
However, depending on your lifestyle and skin jot down, you may have to change it more frequently.
Those with acne-prone skin may consider using a fresh washcloth each day.
Can you use water to remove makeup?
Downie adds that its best to use a bottled cleanser rather than cleanser wipes.
Remember, its always best to apply light pressure with a washcloth as youre cleaning your skin.
Too much pressure can irritate your skin and cause conditions such as dark circles to become aggravated.
For this particular roundup, she spent hours researching different kinds of washcloths and reached out to board-certified dermatologistsDr.
Jeanine B. Downieof Image Dermatology andDr.
Joel L. Cohenof AboutSkin Dermatology and DermSurgery.
Credit: Weezie
Weezie’s Makeup Towels come in a set of two that makes a great gift or guest room addition.Credit: Southern Living / Melanie Fincher
Credit: Amazon
The Ane Face Cleansing Cloths have cotton muslin on one side to polish skin, leaving it smooth and soft.Credit: Southern Living / Nellah McGough
Credit: Amazon
The Original Makeup Eraser Set includes a washcloth for each day of the week plus a mesh storage bag.Credit: Southern Living / Ivy Odom
A light-colored washcloth helps ensure all makeup and dirt are gone—but it may show stains more easily.Credit:Southern Living / Catherine Jessee
