Its a seemingly innocuous question that spurs serious debate.

What Is a Top Sheet?

First things first, let’s clear up any possible confusion.

Buff Coles Cottage Guest Bedroom

Credit: Hector Manuel Sanchez

Some people swear by sleeping with a top sheet, while others absolutely loathe them.

Should You Use a Top Sheet?

(More puzzling: Their survey suggests that 18% of Americans don’t use fitted sheets at all.

Pretty Floral Bedroom

Credit: Photo: Hector Sanchez

I have a lot of questions for those people, but that’s a story for another day.)

Many of our editors have strong pro-top-sheet opinionsnamely, that using one is about as Southern asbuttermilk and cornbread.

“Can’t get more Southern than that.”

A second editor is a little more willing to compromise… sort of.

Here’s what they had to say.

That’s why this debate is so heatedliterally!

Many people find the extra layer of a top sheet hot and restricting.

says Tracy Woodard, co-founder ofCovered in Cotton, a South Carolina maker of throw blankets.

Consider the Design Appeal

“I am pro top sheets!

For me, nothing says bedtime like folding down a crisp sheetanda cozy comforter…

I love a top sheet with beautiful detailing.

A go-to is Matouk’s Callista.

Riley M.America undercover: What do Americans put in their beds?Sleep Junkie.

Published January 16, 2023.