If you hit links we provide, we may receive compensation.

I came acrossCookie Golden Pearl Highlighterin The Cheekleaders Cheek Palette fromBenefit Cosmeticsand it was love at first swipe.

No offense to the other four shades in the palette, but Cookie was a clear favorite.

Benefit Cookie Highlighter on Model

Credit: Ulta

It seems I’m not the only one who shared an instant connection with the wonder product.

Fans loved it so much that Benefit decided to release the belovedhighlighter makeupas a single color.

Benefit Cookie Highlighter

Credit: Ulta

Buy It: $35;ulta.com

Cookie highlighter is available at Ulta Beauty and Sephora stores.

More Must-Shop Products

Kate Spade wristlet with wrist strap

Lawn care items including a Scott’s fertilizer spreader, a manual push lawn mower, and a Fiskars handled shovel

ULTCOVER Rectangular Patio Heavy Duty Table Cover on blue geo background